Spreadsheet or budgeting app: which fits you?
An honest look at when a spreadsheet beats an app, when an app beats a spreadsheet, and a quick test to work out which one you'll actually keep using.
· 4 min read · By the GroFunds team
You’ve tried to get on top of your money before. Maybe it was a spreadsheet that went strong for six weeks and then quietly stopped. Maybe it was an app you opened every day for a month and then forgot about. Now you’re wondering which one to try this time.
The honest answer is that both work, for different people. The best tool is the one you’ll still be using in March. Here’s how to work out which that is for you.
What a spreadsheet is good at
Spreadsheets get dismissed as old fashioned, but they have real strengths.
You control every rule. If you want groceries and household supplies in one line, or your dog’s costs as their own category, you just do it. Nothing decides for you.
You see every number. There’s no hidden logic. If a total looks wrong, you can click into it and find out why.
It’s free and it’s yours. Your data sits in a file you own, and you can keep it as long as you like.
Typing things in makes you notice them. Entering a $14 lunch by hand makes you think about it in a way a list on a screen often doesn’t. For some people that friction is the whole point.
It handles odd situations. Shared costs with a parent, a side business, a savings plan with unusual rules. A spreadsheet bends to fit.
Where spreadsheets struggle
The same freedom causes the problems.
Someone has to type it all. A household with two cards, a chequing account and a partner can easily have 150 transactions a month. Entering them takes time, and it’s the first thing to slip in a busy week.
One missed week breaks the picture. Once you fall behind, catching up feels like a chore, so many people stop altogether.
Formulas break quietly. Insert a row in the wrong place and a total can stop counting the new entries. You might not notice for months.
It’s hard to look ahead. Most budget spreadsheets look back at what happened. Building one that shows where your balance will land before payday is possible, but it takes care. If you want to try, build a month end balance spreadsheet shows how.
Sharing is awkward. Two people editing one file works until both edit at once or one stops updating.
What an app is good at
It fills itself in. Once connected to your bank, transactions arrive on their own. You review rather than type.
It doesn’t fall behind. Skip two weeks and the data is still there when you come back.
It can spot patterns. Bills that come every month, paydays, what you usually spend on food. A good app can find these from your history without you building anything.
It can look forward. Some apps project your balance ahead, so you see a tight week coming instead of discovering it.
Sharing is built in. Many apps let a partner see the same numbers on their own phone.
Where apps struggle
You give up some control. The app sorts transactions its way. You can usually fix them, but you’re working inside someone else’s design.
Connections can need attention. Banks change things, and a connection sometimes needs you to sign in again.
There’s a cost. Many budgeting apps charge a subscription, and you should know the price before you rely on one.
You have to trust it with your data. That’s worth checking properly; how budgeting apps connect to your bank explains what an app can and can’t see.
It’s easy to stop looking. An app that does everything for you can become an app you never open.
A quick test: which one fits you?
Answer these honestly. Tally your answers as you go.
| Question | Points to spreadsheet | Points to app |
|---|---|---|
| Do you enjoy setting things up? | Yes | No |
| How many transactions a month? | Under 50 | Over 50 |
| Do you share money with someone? | No | Yes |
| Have you dropped a manual system before? | No | Yes |
| Do you mostly want to look back or look ahead? | Back | Ahead |
| Is paying for a tool a problem right now? | Yes | No |
If most of your answers land in one column, start there. If it’s an even split, the deciding question is usually the fourth one. If you’ve already given up on a manual system once, the same thing will probably happen again, and that’s not a character flaw. It just means typing every transaction isn’t the job you want.
The middle path
You don’t have to pick only one. You can use both:
- An app for the daily picture, so transactions, bills and balances look after themselves.
- A small spreadsheet for the big decisions, such as a five year savings plan, a wedding budget, or comparing two moving options.
The app covers the boring part. The spreadsheet covers the questions that are too specific to your life for any app to answer well.
Whatever you choose, do this today
The tool matters less than the habit. Pick one, then do these three things before the end of the day:
- Put in your next payday and your bills until then. That’s the information that matters most.
- Set a weekly reminder for a short check in. The 10 minute weekly money check gives you an agenda.
- Decide what “working” looks like. For example: I know by Sunday night whether next week is tight. If your tool gives you that, it’s doing its job.
If you choose an app, GroFunds is one to look at: it connects to your bank accounts with read only access through Plaid, finds your bills and paydays, and shows where the month will land, every day.