Skip to content

Blog

Moved from Mint to Credit Karma and miss budgets? Your options

If you moved from Mint to Credit Karma and miss setting a monthly budget, here are your options, from a simple spreadsheet to a different kind of app.

· 4 min read · By the GroFunds team

When Mint closed, you did the easy thing and moved to Credit Karma. Your accounts came along and you can still see your spending. But something feels missing. You used to set a number for groceries or eating out each month and watch it, and now you’re not sure where that habit went.

This guide is for that gap. It covers what changed, why a budget habit matters, and the ways you can get it back.

What changed

In October 2023, Credit Karma announced that “Mint is going away” and invited Mint users to continue on Credit Karma. The announcement describes tools for tracking net worth and monitoring spending, transactions and cash flow. It doesn’t mention setting budgets. The Mint app then shut down in March 2024.

Products change over time, so check Credit Karma’s own pages for what it offers today. Whatever it offers, if the way you used to budget isn’t there for you any more, the options below still apply.

Why the budget part mattered

Seeing what you spent is useful. Seeing it next to what you meant to spend is what changes behaviour. A budget gives each category a limit you chose yourself, so you can tell at a glance whether this month is on track.

Without that comparison, spending numbers are just history. You find out you overspent on takeout at the end of the month, when it’s too late to do anything about it.

Option 1: A simple budget spreadsheet

You keep tracking accounts wherever you like and run the budget part in a spreadsheet.

How to set it up:

  1. Make a row for each category you care about. Keep it short: groceries, eating out, transport, shopping, personal, subscriptions. Five to eight rows is plenty.
  2. Next to each, put the monthly amount you’re aiming for.
  3. Once a week, add up what you’ve spent in each category so far this month and enter it.
  4. A third column shows what’s left: the budget amount minus spent so far.

That’s it. Twenty minutes a week, and you’ve got your budget habit back.

To pick sensible numbers, base them on your own spending rather than a rule of thumb. Build a budget from your last three months shows how.

Option 2: A paper or envelope style budget

If spreadsheets aren’t your thing, write your categories and amounts on a card or in a notebook. Each time you check your spending, tick off what’s been used. Some people find the physical version easier to stick with because it’s always in sight.

Option 3: A different kind of app

If you want budgeting built in again, you can look at a budgeting app alongside, or instead of, what you use now. Before you sign up for anything, check:

  • how it connects to your bank, and whether that access is read only
  • whether it builds budgets from your real spending or makes you invent numbers
  • whether it treats transfers between your own accounts as spending (it shouldn’t)
  • what it costs, and how cancelling works
  • whether you can share it with a partner if that matters to you

The budgeting app checklist goes through these questions in more detail.

Option 4: Swap the budget for a forecast

Here’s a different thought. Some people who “miss budgets” really miss knowing whether the month is going to be okay. A budget by category answers “am I spending what I planned on groceries?” A forecast answers “where will my balance be on the 30th?”

If the second question is the one that keeps you up, a simple forecast might serve you better than a full budget. Forecast vs budget explains the difference and how to use both.

Keep what’s already working

You don’t have to throw out your current setup to get budgets back. If you like seeing your accounts and spending where you are now, keep that, and add only the missing piece on the side. A one page spreadsheet next to the tool you already open every week is often the least disruptive fix. Change one thing at a time, and you’re far more likely to stick with it.

An example with invented numbers

Here’s a small weekly budget check in a spreadsheet, on the 15th of the month.

CategoryBudgetSpent so farLeft
Groceries$700$380$320
Eating out$250$190$60
Transport$300$140$160
Shopping$200$230$30 over
Subscriptions$60$60$0

Halfway through the month, two things stand out. Shopping is already $30 over, and eating out has only $60 left for two weeks. Groceries and transport are on track. That’s the kind of nudge a budget gives: you can ease off eating out now instead of finding out on the 31st.

Picking which option

  • Want it simple and in your control: spreadsheet or paper.
  • Want it automatic and in one place: another app.
  • Mostly worried about running short: a forecast, with or without a category budget.

Whichever you choose, try it for two full months before judging it. New habits take a few weeks to feel normal.

GroFunds is one option if you want both in one place: it builds budgets from your own spending and shows where the month will land, every day. It’s coming soon to iPhone in Canada and the US.