Paying insurance monthly or yearly: what it does to cash flow
Monthly or once a year? How each way of paying for insurance changes your month, what to ask your insurer, and how to switch without a crunch.
· 4 min read · By the GroFunds team
When you buy or renew a car, home or tenant insurance policy, you’re often asked how you want to pay: all at once, in a couple of instalments, or monthly. It’s a quick question on a form, and most people pick whatever sounds easiest at the time.
That choice decides how insurance shows up in your month for the next year. This article looks at it from one angle only: your cash flow. It isn’t about which policy or insurer to choose.
Two ways the same cost can land
Here is an example with invented numbers. A household’s car insurance costs $1,440 for the year.
| Paid yearly | Paid monthly | |
|---|---|---|
| Renewal month | $1,440 out | $120 out |
| Every other month | $0 | $120 out |
| Total for the year | $1,440 | $1,440, plus any fee or charge for paying monthly |
Over a year the cost is about the same, unless paying monthly adds something (more on that below). What changes is the shape of your months.
What paying monthly does to your month
It’s predictable. $120 comes out on the same date every month. You can line it up with payday and forget about it.
It’s always there. Every month carries the cost, including tight ones. When you’re working out how much you can spend until payday, it’s one more line on the list.
It may cost a little more. Whether paying in instalments changes the total depends on your insurer and your policy. You only find out by asking (see the questions below).
A missed payment matters. If a monthly payment fails because the account is short that day, something will follow from it. Ask your insurer what, and find out before it happens, not after.
What paying yearly does to your month
Eleven months are lighter. No insurance line at all for most of the year.
One month is much heavier. $1,440 landing in one month can knock the whole month out of shape, especially if the renewal falls near other big bills.
It needs planning. Paying yearly works well if you’ve set money aside for it ahead of time. Without that, the renewal turns into a scramble. The usual way to handle it is to set aside a twelfth each month in a separate account, so the money is there when the bill comes. For that, see sinking funds explained.
Questions to ask your insurer
Before your next renewal, call or check your account and ask:
- “Is the total cost for the year different if I pay monthly instead of in full?”
- “Is there a fee for paying by instalments, and how much is it?”
- “What payment dates can I choose?”
- “If a monthly payment doesn’t go through, what happens and how long do I have?”
- “Can I switch how I pay partway through the policy, or only at renewal?”
Write down the answers. They’re specific to your insurer and your policy, so there’s no general rule to rely on.
Which suits your cash flow
There’s no single right answer. A few questions can help you see which fits you better:
- Is your month already tight? If most months end close to zero, a big annual charge is harder to absorb. Monthly may be easier until you have a buffer.
- Do you already set money aside for annual bills? If you have a system for annual bills, adding insurance to it is easy, and paying yearly may cost less if your insurer charges for instalments.
- When is your renewal? A renewal in December, next to holiday spending, or in the same month as property tax, is harder to handle in one go.
- How many policies do you have? Car, home and life insurance all renewing at different times can make it hard to keep track. Some people put all their insurance on one payment style so it’s easier to follow.
Switching from monthly to yearly, slowly
If you’d like to pay yearly but can’t find the full amount right now, you can build up to it:
- Keep paying monthly for this policy year.
- Each month, also set aside a twelfth of next year’s estimated premium in a separate account.
- At renewal, if the money is there, pay in full. If you’re not quite there, stay monthly one more year and keep setting aside.
That year costs more out of each month for a while, because you’re paying this year’s premium and saving for next year’s. If that’s too much, set aside half the amount and take two years to get there.
Switching from yearly to monthly
If the annual payment is the thing that breaks your month, switching to monthly can make the next renewal manageable. Ask your insurer when you can switch and whether it changes the total. Then put the monthly date a few days after your payday.
Whichever you choose, pick the date
The payment date matters as much as the payment style. A monthly premium that comes out the day before payday sits at the lowest point of your month. Ask whether it can move to a few days after payday instead. For a yearly premium, the renewal date comes with the policy, so mark it on your calendar a month ahead and check that the money set aside is really there.
Look at it every renewal
Your situation changes, and so do insurers’ rules. Each time a policy renews, take five minutes to check the payment style still suits your month.
GroFunds finds your insurance payments in your bank accounts, whether they come monthly or once a year, and includes them when it shows where the month will land.