Autopay: when it helps and when it bites
Automatic payments stop you forgetting bills, but the timing can catch you on a low balance day. How to set autopay up so it works for you.
· 4 min read · By the GroFunds team
Autopay sounds like the grown up way to handle bills: set it once, never miss a due date again. For a lot of bills, that’s exactly how it works.
But autopay doesn’t know what’s in your account. It takes the money on the date you agreed to, whether payday came yet or not. If you’ve ever had a bill bounce on the one day your balance was low, you know the other side of it.
Here’s how to keep the good part and avoid the bite.
What autopay is good at
- You don’t forget. A payment missed because you forgot is the easiest kind to avoid, and autopay avoids it.
- It’s one less job. Every bill you don’t have to pay by hand is a little less to keep track of.
- It’s predictable. The same date every month makes your month easier to plan, as long as you know the date.
For fixed bills that never change, like rent paid by transfer, a phone plan or a streaming service, autopay is usually a good fit.
Where autopay goes wrong
It ignores payday
A bill set to come out on the 1st doesn’t care that you’re paid on the 5th. If your account is lowest just before payday, that’s exactly when an autopay bill can push it below zero. The lowest point in your month is often the few days before payday, and a bill that lands then is the one that hurts.
It hides changes
When you pay by hand, you see the amount. With autopay, a bill that jumps from $90 to $160 just goes through. Variable bills like utilities, or any subscription that raises its price, can drift up for months before you notice.
It keeps going after you stop using something
A gym you stopped visiting, an app you forgot about: autopay keeps paying until you stop it. That’s how a subscription can outlive its usefulness by months.
It can stack up
If several bills are set to come out on the same day or the same week, they can drain the account together even if each one alone is fine.
Set autopay up to work with your payday
Here is an example with invented numbers. Payday is the 15th and the last day of the month. Before:
| Bill | Amount | Autopay date |
|---|---|---|
| Phone | $70 | 12th |
| Car insurance | $130 | 13th |
| Internet | $85 | 14th |
| Gym | $45 | 14th |
| Out in the three days before the 15th | $330 |
All four bills land in the three days before payday, when the account is lowest. After moving the dates:
| Bill | Amount | Autopay date |
|---|---|---|
| Phone | $70 | 17th |
| Car insurance | $130 | 17th |
| Internet | $85 | 2nd |
| Gym | $45 | 2nd |
The same $330 now comes out a couple of days after each payday, when the money is there. Some providers let you change the date by phone or in your account, so it’s worth asking. The guide to lining up your bills with your payday has a short script for asking.
Which bills to put on autopay
A simple way to decide:
- Fixed amount, essential, comes out after payday: good candidates. Phone, internet, insurance, loan payments.
- Variable amount: autopay is fine if you check the amount each month, or set a calendar reminder a few days before. Utilities and credit card statements fall here.
- Things you might cancel: think twice. For subscriptions you aren’t sure about, paying by hand or checking often keeps them visible.
- Bills that land before payday and can’t move: keep a buffer in the account so the payment clears, or pay these by hand on payday.
Check autopay once a month
Autopay should save you work, not hide things from you. Once a month, take five minutes to:
- Look at every automatic payment that came out last month.
- Compare the amounts with the month before. Any jump is worth a look.
- Ask yourself whether you still use each subscription.
- Check the dates still line up with your payday.
How to stop an automatic payment
If you want to stop one, the steps depend on where you live.
In Canada, automatic withdrawals from a bank account are called preauthorized debits. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says that to cancel one you must notify the biller in writing, keep a copy of the notice, and check that the withdrawals stop. If they continue and you’re not satisfied with the biller’s response, FCAC says you have 90 days to ask your financial institution for a reimbursement. The same page says that if the amount can vary, the biller must give you written notice at least 10 days before the withdrawal, unless you agreed to waive or shorten that.
In the US, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says you have the right to stop automatic payments from your account, even if you allowed them before. It suggests telling both the company and your bank or credit union that you’ve withdrawn permission, following up in writing, and keeping records of your requests.
In both countries, stopping the payment doesn’t cancel what you owe or any contract you signed. If you’re ending a service, cancel the service too.
A middle path: reminders instead of autopay
If autopay makes you nervous but you keep forgetting due dates, set calendar reminders instead. A reminder two days before each bill gives you time to check the balance and pay it yourself. It’s a bit more work, but nothing happens without you seeing it.
GroFunds finds your bills and paydays from your bank accounts and shows where the month will land, so you can see whether an autopay date falls on a low balance day before it does.