The real monthly cost of a car, beyond the payment
Insurance, fuel, maintenance, registration, parking and tires: how to add up what your car really costs each month, using your own statements.
· 5 min read · By the GroFunds team
Ask someone what their car costs and they’ll usually give you one number: the monthly payment, or zero if the car is paid off. That’s the number they see on a schedule. The rest arrives at odd times, in odd amounts, from a dozen different places, and it’s the rest that throws a month off.
This post walks through every cost a car brings with it, how to find your own numbers in your statements, and how to turn them into one honest monthly figure.
The costs that come with a car
Here’s the full list. Not every line applies to you, but go through all of them before you decide.
Regular, on a schedule
- Insurance. Monthly or once a year, depending on how you pay. If you pay yearly, it’s still a monthly cost, just collected in one go. There’s more on that in paying insurance monthly or yearly.
- Parking. A monthly spot at work or at home, a residential permit, or a building’s parking fee.
- Fuel or charging. Weekly or more, and it moves with how much you drive and the price at the pump.
Regular, but not monthly
- Registration or plate renewal. Usually once a year or every couple of years, depending on where you live. Your province or state’s licensing office sends the notice.
- Driver’s licence renewal. Every few years.
- Oil changes and routine service. Every few months, depending on the car and how you drive.
- Seasonal tires and the swap. In much of Canada, switching between winter and all season tires twice a year, and buying a new set every few years.
- Inspections or emissions tests, where your area requires them.
Irregular, but certain
- Repairs. Brakes, batteries, wipers, a cracked windshield. You don’t know when, but you know they’ll come.
- Tolls, car washes, parking meters. Small amounts that rarely get counted.
- Tickets. Nobody plans for them, and nobody gets none forever.
Find your own numbers
Averages from someone else’s car won’t help you. Your car, your commute and your city make the numbers. The best source is your own last twelve months.
Open your bank and card statements for the past year and search for:
- your insurer’s name
- the gas stations you use, or your charging network
- the garage or dealer that services your car
- your parking provider
- the licensing or registration office
- tire shops
- toll operators
A year matters because so many car costs come once or twice a year. Three months of statements would miss the registration renewal, the tire swap and the brake job, and you’d think your car was cheaper than it is.
Turn it into one monthly number
Add each line up for the year, then divide by twelve. Here’s an example with invented numbers for a paid off car:
| Cost | Per year | Per month |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance | $1,920 | $160 |
| Fuel | $2,400 | $200 |
| Parking permit | $360 | $30 |
| Registration | $120 | $10 |
| Oil changes and service | $480 | $40 |
| Tire swap twice, plus a share of new tires | $360 | $30 |
| Repairs (brakes, battery) | $900 | $75 |
| Tolls, washes, meters | $240 | $20 |
| Total | $6,780 | $565 |
This household would have said their car costs “nothing, it’s paid off.” It actually costs about $565 a month. That’s not a reason to sell it. It’s the number that belongs in the budget.
If you have a monthly payment as well, add it on top. The point of this list is everything else.
Put the uneven costs on a schedule
Knowing the monthly figure is half of it. The other half is having the money there when the uneven bills arrive. A $900 brake job in a month with no room is what turns a car into a crisis.
Split your list in two:
- Costs you pay as they come: fuel, monthly parking, monthly insurance. These go in your normal monthly spending.
- Costs that come in lumps: registration, tires, service, repairs, yearly insurance. Add these up, divide by twelve, and move that amount into a separate savings account every payday.
In the example, the lumpy costs are registration, service, tires and repairs: $1,860 a year, or $155 a month. Moving $155 every month means the brake job is already paid for when it happens. This is a sinking fund, and sinking funds explained has more on setting one up.
Then put the dates you do know on a calendar: the registration renewal month, the insurance renewal, the two tire swap weeks. Annual bills that catch people out covers how to spot them in your statements.
Ways to bring the number down
Once you can see each line, you can work on the biggest ones first:
- Shop your insurance at renewal. Get quotes from other insurers before your policy renews, with the same coverage, so you’re comparing like with like. Ask your current insurer what discounts you qualify for.
- Look at how you drive. Fuel is often the biggest line you control. Combining errands into one trip, keeping tires at the right pressure and taking transit for one commute a week all show up in the fuel line.
- Do the small service jobs on time. Routine service costs less than the repair you get from skipping it.
- Check parking. A monthly spot you use three days a week might cost more than paying daily.
- Count it before the next car. If you’re thinking about a different car, run this same list for it first. A cheaper car with expensive insurance or parking can cost more each month.
Do this today
- Search the last twelve months of statements for every line above.
- Add up the year and divide by twelve.
- Split the list into “as they come” and “in lumps”.
- Start a monthly transfer for the lumps, sized from your own numbers.
When you’re done, you’ll have a car number you can trust, and the next repair bill will be a line on a list instead of a surprise. If you want this done without the search, GroFunds connects your accounts with read only access through Plaid, finds your regular bills and learns what you usually spend on things like fuel, so the real cost of the car is already in where the month will land.