Skip to content

Blog

Transfers aren't spending: why your budget looks wrong

If your spending total looks hundreds or thousands too high, money moving between your own accounts is the usual cause. Here's how to spot it and fix it.

· 4 min read · By the GroFunds team

You add up last month and the total is alarming. Your spending says $6,200, but you know your take home pay was $4,800, and you didn’t go into debt or empty your savings. Something doesn’t add up.

Usually nothing is wrong with your spending. What’s wrong is that money moving between your own accounts got counted as if it left your life. Fixing that is often the single biggest correction you can make to your numbers.

What counts as a transfer

A transfer is money that moves from one of your pockets to another. You still have it; it’s just somewhere else. Common examples:

  • chequing to savings, and back again
  • chequing to a joint account you share with a partner
  • paying your own credit card balance
  • moving money between two banks you use
  • topping up a cash or prepaid account you own

Spending is money that leaves you and goes to someone else in exchange for something: the supermarket, your landlord, the phone company.

How transfers get counted twice

Here’s the trap, shown as an example with invented numbers.

You buy $90 of groceries on your credit card. A few weeks later, you pay the card from chequing. Your two accounts now show:

AccountTransactionAmount
Credit cardSupermarket$90 out
ChequingPayment to credit card$90 out

If you add up everything going out, you get $180. But you only bought $90 of food. The $90 card payment is the same money, counted a second time on its way to settle the bill.

Savings work the same way. Move $400 to savings on payday and it looks like $400 spent. Move $200 back two weeks later and it looks like $200 of income. Neither happened. You moved your own money around.

The three places it shows up

Credit card payments. If you put most of your spending on a card, your card payment can be close to your entire monthly spending, and it’s counted again in full. This is the largest double count for most households.

Savings back and forth. People who sweep money to savings and pull it back when things get tight can see their “spending” and “income” both inflated every month.

Shared accounts. If you send money to a joint account and pay bills from there, the transfer in and the bills out both look like spending unless you mark the transfer.

A month, before and after

Here’s a fuller example, again with invented numbers, for one person with a chequing account, a savings account and one credit card.

What happenedCounted as spending beforeReal spending
Rent from chequing$1,600$1,600
Card purchases (food, gas, shopping)$1,450$1,450
Card payment from chequing$1,450$0
Phone and internet$140$140
Transfer to savings$500$0
Transfer from savings back to chequing(shown as income)$0
Total$5,140$3,190

The first total makes the month look like a disaster. The second shows a month that fits inside the paycheque with room to spare. It’s the same bank statement.

How to fix it in your own numbers

If you track by hand:

  1. Go through last month and highlight every payment to a credit card, every move to or from savings, and every move to an account you own.
  2. Give them all one label, such as “Transfer.”
  3. Leave that label out of every spending total and every income total.

If you use an app: look for a category called “Transfer” or similar and check that card payments and moves between your accounts land there. Many apps mark these, but they can miss some, especially transfers to an account at a different bank. Correct the ones that slip through, and set a rule if the app allows it.

What isn’t a transfer

Some payments look like transfers but are real costs. Be careful with these:

  • Loan and mortgage payments. The money goes to a lender, not to your own pocket, and the original purchase (the house, the car) isn’t in your monthly spending already. Treat the payment as a bill.
  • Money sent to another person. Paying a friend back for concert tickets, or sending money to family, leaves your household. That’s spending, even if it was sent the same way as a transfer.
  • Fees and interest. Interest charged on a card is a real cost, even though it appears on the card statement.

The test is simple: after the money moved, do you or your household still have it? If yes, it’s a transfer. If no, it’s spending.

Why this matters beyond the total

Getting transfers right does more than fix a scary number.

  • Your categories become trustworthy. Without the double count, you can see what you really spend on food or transport. Categorising transactions has a simple system to go with this.
  • Your normal becomes clear. Comparing months only works if each month is counted the same way. See is this month normal?
  • You stop feeling broke when you’re not. An inflated spending total can make a fine month feel like failure.

Do this now

Open last month’s transactions and find your credit card payment. Compare it with your total card purchases for the month. If they’re close, that’s your double count, and you’ve just found the reason your budget looked wrong.

GroFunds connects your bank accounts with read only access through Plaid and builds budgets from your own spending, so getting this right once pays off every month.