Skip to content

Blog

Why your paycheque is smaller than you expected

Salary divided by pay periods rarely matches what lands in your account. Read your pay stub line by line, and plan around the take home number.

· 4 min read · By the GroFunds team

You took the job at $60,000 a year. Paid every two weeks, that should be about $2,300 a cheque. Then the first deposit lands and it’s well under $2,000.

Nothing has gone wrong. The number in your offer letter is your gross pay, before anything comes off. What reaches your account is your net pay, or take home pay. The difference is a set of deductions, and once you can read them, the smaller number stops being a surprise.

Gross pay vs net pay

  • Gross pay: your salary or hourly wage for the period, before deductions.
  • Net pay: what’s left after your employer takes off what it’s required to, plus anything you’ve signed up for.

Your budget should always be built on net pay. A plan built on gross pay is short from day one.

What usually comes off in Canada

The CRA’s payroll pages list the three main source deductions employers handle: income tax, Canada Pension Plan (CPP) contributions and Employment Insurance (EI) premiums. You can read how employers work them out on the CRA’s page on calculating payroll deductions and contributions.

How much income tax comes off depends partly on the TD1 Personal Tax Credits Return you fill in for your employer. If you skipped it or filled it in quickly on your first day, it’s worth looking at again.

What usually comes off in the US

The IRS’s page on understanding employment taxes says employers generally must withhold federal income tax and Social Security and Medicare taxes from wages.

How much federal income tax is withheld depends on the withholding certificate you gave your employer when you started. The IRS has a free Tax Withholding Estimator that helps you check it and can produce a filled in form to hand back if you want to change it. It’s worth running after a big life change, like a new job, a second job or a new baby, because the form you filled in years ago may no longer fit.

The deductions you chose

Beyond the required ones, your pay stub may list things you signed up for, sometimes without noticing on a busy first day:

  • health, dental or vision coverage
  • a workplace pension or retirement plan contribution
  • life or disability insurance
  • union dues
  • parking, transit or a gym program through work
  • charitable giving through payroll

Each one is usually a reasonable choice. But together they can take a noticeable bite, and they’re the part of the gap you have the most say over.

Read your pay stub, line by line

Find your latest pay stub (your employer’s payroll portal usually has it) and go through it with a pen.

  1. Find gross pay for the period. Check the hours or salary match what you expect.
  2. List every deduction with its amount. Mark each as required (tax and the government plans above) or chosen.
  3. Find net pay. It should equal gross minus all deductions. If it doesn’t, ask payroll.
  4. Look at the year to date column. If a deduction appears in some pay periods but not others, that explains why some cheques look different.

Here’s an example with invented numbers for one biweekly pay:

LineAmount
Gross pay$2,300
Income tax$330 out
Government pension and insurance$160 out
Health and dental plan$45 out
Workplace retirement plan$70 out
Net pay$1,695

The required deductions in this example add up to $490. The chosen ones add up to $115. That $1,695 is the number your budget needs.

Why one cheque can differ from the next

Even with the same salary, cheques can vary:

  • Your first cheque may cover a partial period or include setup amounts. Your first paycheque at a new job covers that gap.
  • Overtime, bonuses or commission change the gross, and the tax on a larger cheque can look high in that single pay.
  • A benefit starts or stops partway through the year.
  • A raise shows up a pay or two after it was announced, sometimes with a catch up amount.

If a cheque looks very different from the last one, compare the two stubs side by side. The changed line is usually obvious.

Budget on the right number

Once you know your real net pay, use it everywhere:

  • For the monthly picture, multiply net pay by your number of pays in a year and divide by twelve. Or, on biweekly pay, plan on two cheques a month and treat the extra ones separately. Biweekly pay, monthly bills shows how.
  • For the next two weeks, start from the net amount that will land, then subtract the bills due before the next payday. The free payday check does this for you.

When to ask questions

Ask payroll if:

  • net pay doesn’t equal gross minus the listed deductions
  • a deduction appears that you don’t recognize
  • a deduction you cancelled is still there
  • the hours or rate are wrong

For questions about how much tax should come off your pay, the CRA and IRS pages linked above are the place to start, or a tax professional if your situation is complicated.

A smaller cheque than you expected is frustrating once. After you’ve read the stub, it’s just a number, and a plan built on it is one that holds.